Showing posts with label Copyright Infringement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Copyright Infringement. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 21, 2023

How is Copyright Protection Applicable to the Indian Music Industry?

 However, are you aware that before playing the famous songs publicly, you need to have all the permissions in place from the makers of such songs? If you fail to do so, you shall end up finding yourself in big trouble like Copyright Infringement. Here in this article, we shall be thoroughly discussing Copyright Protection in the Indian music industry. We shall answer a few questions, including:



  • How can you save yourself from receiving a copyright claim?
  • Are there provisions in the Indian Copyright Act allowing remixing an old song to a new song?

The term ‘copyright’ combines two words, copy and right; therefore, we can also say that copyright refers to the legitimate and exclusive rights of the individual or entity owning the creative Intellectual Property (IP) assets.

Ian Richard Hargreaves CBE, Emeritus Professor at Cardiff University, Wales, the United Kingdom, has stated that the copyright system can’t be considered appropriate for the present digital age as millions of individuals infringe upon the creative works of others on an everyday basis by simply switching video or audio files from one device to another.

Copyright protection in the music industry gives the producers exclusive legal ownership of creative musical works and recordings. It also includes the exclusive right to distribute, reproduce, and license the copyrighted work to obtain royalties. Kindly note that when lyrics and music are recorded, written on paper, or otherwise placed in a document, the copyright in the creative work is automatically created. The United States Copyright Office has mentioned that once a sound is captured, implying that it must be recorded on a medium that could be sensed, copied, or otherwise transmitted, the master recording is copyright protected in digital tracks, tapes, optical disks, or any other format. However, it is highly advisable to go ahead with copyright registration of your song or musical work. To do the same, you need to ensure that it is tangible, fill out the required copyright application form at the copyright office, and pay the prescribed fee.

Musical Works under the Indian Copyright Act of 1957

Under Section 2(P) of the Indian Copyright Act of 1957 (referred to as Act further in this article), a musical work is defined and is said to include works composed of music containing graphic symbols. An original song is formalized, decorated, modified, and transferred to the original work’s category. You can use sounds to create new musical works by mixing, adding, and deleting some specific aspects of the original song. In India, Bollywood movie songs are loved by everyone. We have listened to the legendary 90s Dheere Dheere Se Meri Zindagi Mein Aana, featuring Rahul Roy and Anu Agarwal, and its remake by Yo Yo Honey Singh. The question that now arises is whether it is legitimate to exploit an artist’s original creative work in this way? In this scenario, the new music or remix is created using audio mixing and adding and subtracting some aspects of the original song.

As per Section 52(1)(j) of the Act, certain uses and modifications of creative works, including sound recordings and music, require obtaining the owner’s consent. It talks about obtaining a legal license to use a copyrighted work in a specific way, provided that the individual or entity (i.e., the licensee) pays the required fee and complies well with the law.

In the case of Gramophone Co v. Super Cassettes, the court held that obtaining the permission of the original owner to use a piece of his creative musical work is necessary. However, in Gramophone Co v. Mars, the court had the opposite opinion. It held that as long as the requirements of Section 52(1)(j) are followed, there might be no instance of copyright infringement and no necessity to obtain the owner’s consent (consent requirement is only for the first recording).

The whole world of music copyright law is undoubtedly complicated; however, it is not that tough to safeguard a piece of musical work and obtain royalties for it. You only need to register your copyright, join the necessary debt collection agency, and pick a distributor. Don’t forget that registering your copyright shall protect your creative work and prevent theft, misuse, and infringement.

Thursday, December 5, 2019

How Copyright Infringement Takes Place on the Internet

Copyright Infringement Takes Place on the Internet




One can never deny the fact that the Internet is indeed one of man's profound inventions and innovations of the millennium. The Internet refers to the global network of interconnected computers and networks, which is accessible at a negligible cost, and to almost every other person on the planet. While being the quickest source of information, the Internet, however, is both a boon and bane. Copyright owners across the globe often refer to the Internet as a curse more than a blessing. The reason behind the same lies in the fact that the Internet is the most predominant threat to their corresponding Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) associated with a Copyright. Let's first make ourselves familiar with why the Internet poses a threat to the unique creations of the Copyright holders by considering the points specified below:
  1. The Internet is accessible to any person and at any time without considerable impediments.
  2. It offers a platform for wide dispersion and distribution of information quickly within a few clicks.
  3. The cost associated with distribution is almost next to nil.
  4. The original creation and its replica or copies aren’t easy to distinguish.
The widespread usage of the Internet has given rise to various legal disputes and lawsuits concerning copyright infringement. As the infringement takes place in the digital networks, the courts and legal authorities often face difficulties while analyzing the issues and coming to a decision. Moreover, copyright infringement not only includes information but also extends to movies, photos, pictures, videos, audio-visuals, and other multimedia. Such material can easily be uploaded and downloaded as well, with no efforts required at all.

INFRINGEMENT OF COPYRIGHT ON THE INTERNET

Copyright Infringement on the Internet has nowadays become more prevalent than ever before. Due to its characteristics, the Internet is undoubtedly a threat to copyright owners. The peculiar feature of copyright infringement on the Internet is the point that it is arduous to determine whether a work is a copy of the original creation or not. On the other hand, making a distinction in the tangible medium is a completely hassle-free process. It is imperative to make a point of the fact that infringement may not always be intentional; it can be due to ignorance as well.
On the Internet, possible copyright infringement can take in several forms. Let us discuss each of these different avatars one by one.
  1. FRAMING - It refers to the process in which a website is allowed to include the contents from another independent website in its frame such that the framing website appears as the original one. In framing, every frame functions independently, due to which, the information downloaded in one frame stays inside it without overlapping with any other frame. Consequently, the users remain at the framing website and view its content by staying unaware of the fact that the content comes from another framed website.
  2. LINKING - Linking refers to the process of connecting the users from the original website to a linked website. The user is given access to the linked website on the original website itself with no need of typing the URL separately. For research purposes, linking proves to be beneficial to the users; however, it gives rise to several different legal issues.
  3. CACHING - Caching refers to the process in which a material is copied from its source to cache (space of temporary storage). The material shall be available to the users for a temporary period. Caching can be executed in several ways, for instance - copying a document displayed on the computer screen while accessing the web.
  4. PUBLIC DISPLAY OF RIGHT IN POSTING OR UPLOADING
When any creative work is published or uploaded on the Internet, there is no restriction on its viewing. Hence, when copyrighted material is posted without authorization, it becomes an issue of infringement. Although the courts and legal authorities haven't given any straightforward formula to arrive at such a conclusion, they still have delivered mixed responses and decisions as per the facts of each case.
  1. ARCHIVING
It refers to the process of downloading and storing the content or material of one website and incorporating the same in another. Archiving - without taking the legal permission from the owner may amount to infringement.

 Ref- https://www.kashishworld.com/blog/how-copyright-infringement-takes-place-on-the-internet/

Monday, December 2, 2019

Protecting Ideas and Innovations Using Three Types of Intellectual Property (IP)

For protecting an idea so that someone else can't steal it, it is essential to secure one or more of the different forms of Intellectual Property (IP). Quite often, every invention begins as its owner's trade secret. Hence, there is a need to go ahead with Trademark Registration, Patent Protection, or Copyright Registration and have Intellectual Property Protection in hand before marketing the innovations or inventions. Most of the people around the world are not aware of the fact or haven't yet fully realized that they can protect their innovations using various forms of IP. Let us consider an example to have a better understanding of this concept. The brand 'Coca-Cola' is a trademark; its recipe is a trade secret; Copyright Protection is there on its packaging art, and its bottle or Can are protected by both a design patent and trademark in the form of trade dress. In the same manner, your unique product or invention can also seek protection by more than one type of IP. It is imperative to parse out which aspects of your innovation are suitable for Trademark Protection, patent protection, and copyright protection, respectively.


TRADEMARK

Safeguarding a brand's name deserves the utmost importance as one would never want to invest time and money at a later stage after finding out that someone else is already using his or her registered mark. A trademark is a name, symbol, or sign associated with a product or service and is known to protect a brand. To be specific, a trademark is anything that helps the customers in identifying a product or its source. Moreover, other things like color, sound, or smell can serve as a trademark too. The most common types of trademark include logos, watermarks, and slogans. If you are planning to go ahead with trademark registration, start by protecting the wordmark first and then seek trademark protection for the other aspects of your product as a part of your overall marketing and business strategy.  Besides, it is highly advisable to conduct a thorough search before filing a Trademark Application and ensure that nobody else is using a similar mark.

COPYRIGHT

Almost every product can seek copyright protection for at least one of its aspects. For instance - the images or words on the product's packaging, its label, and the product itself; can all be protected with a copyright. A few advantages of copyright registration include that the process is inexpensive, and the copyright is comparatively easier to secure. Copyright protection extends to the original and creative works of authorship that are fixed in a tangible medium of expression. It implies that creative or innovative works have been either written or drawn on paper, saved on an electronic storage device, or preserved in some other tangible format.
A few examples of copyrightable works include videos, articles, movies, books, software, and photos. Copyright protection doesn't extend to ideas or useful items, which fall under patent protection. It is a matter of fact that yes - software is a functional item, yet it can get copyright protection due to the creativity involved in the entire process of selecting, ordering, and arranging multiple pieces of code in the software.

PATENT

A patent offers an owner or inventor the exclusive rights to his or her invention and excludes others from using, selling, manufacturing, distributing, or licensing the product until the term of patent protection. Generally, a patent is defined using three attributes, namely, newness, non-obviousness, and usefulness. Patent protection helps in establishing a healthy market position as your new idea or invention can prove to a great differentiator among your business competitors. Also, you can commercialize the concept to earn higher returns on your investment. An interesting thing about receiving a patent is that even if you don't have enough time to exploit your invention, you can still license or sell it for generating a new income stream. Without patent protection, the world economy shall become a place of less creativity, innovation, and discovery.

Ref- https://www.kashishworld.com/blog/protecting-ideas-and-innovations-using-three-types-of-intellectual-property-ip/

Wednesday, October 23, 2019

Artificial Intelligence and Copyrights

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been continuously gaining widespread and intense momentum in today's ever-evolving tech-savvy world. With the incorporation of complicated technologies, the AI systems are capable of coming up with astounding inventions and innovations over a matter of time. AI systems can easily create complex works like art, poetry, to name a few, and perform calculations.  However, now the question is whether these works are also capable of getting Intellectual Property (IP) Protection under the Intellectual Property Law, just like any other invention or work produced by human beings or not.


UNDERSTANDING THE TERM ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE

In simple words, Artificial Intelligence or AI refers to the ability of a computer system to make the decisions and do the required processing on its own. It is also defined as the task of processing or acting on information such that the results are synonymous with how an intelligent human being would have responded to in the same situation. After the introduction of AI technology, the question that now arises is whether the creation or output rendered by an AI system is a result of the system's intelligence or its creator. AI-enabled systems have now also gathered the attention of legal Intellectual Property (IP) authorities when computer work is at times denied copyright by the Registrar of Copyrights because of indeterminate legal status.

LINK BETWEEN AI AND COPYRIGHTS

A copyright is an exclusive legal right or an Intellectual Property Right (IPR) granted to the owner or the creator of original work for his unique creation. The subject-matter of copyright includes two things - the work should be original and in tangible form. Generally, copyrights are granted for literary and artistic works. As the creation of literary and artistic works is a contemporary area of the applications of AI systems, the concept of copyrights in the field of Artificial Intelligence is therefore relevant.

COPYRIGHT PROTECTION AND AI

Even after several judgments, the debate regarding the ambiguity of stance continues. The National Commission on New Technological Uses of Copyrighted Works has mentioned in its report that the capability of AI technology or systems to create practical work is theoretical and not practical. On the other hand, the Office of Technology Assessment has a different viewpoint and suggested that AI works can be treated as legitimate co-authors or co-creators of copyrighted works.
Even if the countries agree to grant copyrights to AI works, then there will be another point of discussion about who shall be the copyright owner. As of now, the current law requires a legal person to be the IP right holder. Another loophole is that, if AI systems are sold or purchased, then copyrights shall be granted to the buyer or shall remain with the creator. Many countries, including New Zealand and England, favor the creator in such circumstances. The critical issue in the present legal system is who would bear the criminal liability of AI works. As per the current law, criminal liability falls upon the creator or programmer. Hence the law requires some immediate consideration for removing the loopholes.

REMEDIES AND SUGGESTIONS

  1. UNIFORM RECOGNITION - As AI systems have achieved recognition only in a few selected nations, including the US, England, and New Zealand, all other countries must come forward as well and take a positive initiative towards the recognition of such systems.
  2. NO AMBIGUITY - With the advent of AI-enabled systems, the confusion regarding Copyright Laws must be removed by the legal authorities and departments as with widespread solutions rendered by AI technology, the protection of such works is now a critical question for every nation.
  3. NEW LAW OR ACT - In the present era, AI systems are performing human-like functionality in almost every sphere of life. Therefore, the nations must come up with a new act or law for AI works, which shall further provide adequate remedies for both civil and criminal offenses and remove the unnecessary liability of the creator.
BOTTOM LINE
The current IP Law related to Artificial Intelligence is problematic since the recognition of work generated by AI-enabled systems in under ambiguity. Therefore, some well-defined and precise legislative rules and regulations are necessary to deal with the issue. With the widespread implementation and usage of AI techniques in our day-to-day lives, there is a need to implement proper guidelines regarding the registration and protection of AI works as IP urgently in every nation.

Ref- https://www.kashishworld.com/blog/artificial-intelligence-and-copyrights/

Wednesday, October 16, 2019

Paparazzi Agency Sues Jennifer Lopez Alleging Copyright Infringement

Quite often, it is celebrities versus paparazzi in court. However, this time, some photo agencies are fighting back, and the latest star and celebrity sued for using a paparazzi photo, without the legal permission, happens to be none other than Jennifer Lopez. One of the leading paparazzi shops, Splash News and Picture Agency, has recently filed a lawsuit against Lopez in the US District Court for the Central District of California. The lawsuit accuses her of two claims of Copyright Infringement for posting a Splash picture of her holding hands with fiancé Alex Rodriguez while they were out for breakfast in New York in 2017 on her official Instagram account. The lawsuit is looking forward to seeking monetary damages worth $150,000 for each claim.



As per the lawsuit filed, Splash had never licensed that particular picture to Lopez, and she used it without any legal authorization or permission. According to the professionals and experts in this field, photographs clicked of celebrities like Lopez and Rodriguez are worth big dollars to photo agencies, who are always looking for opportunities to capture boldfaced names in public. They sell the rights for the use of such pictures to celebrity magazines, tabloids, and mainstream newspapers.

The lawsuit has claimed that the photograph is valuable, distinctive, and creative. Furthermore, it has also stated that Splash and its photographer had stood to gain revenue from licensing the photograph since it was visually appealing and of high-quality, and involved celebrity status. However, Lopez's unauthorized use has harmed both the already existing and the future market for the original picture.

So, a picture of Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez, taken without their consent, which according to the First Amendment (Copyright Law), isn't required, since she was out in public at that time - doesn't belong to her and would have to seek permission in turn from the photo agency and pay them as well for posting the picture on her social media account. On her official Instagram account, Lopez has 102 million followers.

As per various Intellectual Property (IP) experts and specialists, the Copyright Law considers a photograph as an original work of authorship, just like a book, painting, or poetry. Moreover, the general rule also states that the person who clicks or takes a photograph owns the copyright.

Ref-https://www.kashishworld.com/blog/paparazzi-agency-sues-jennifer-lopez-alleging-copyright-infringement/

Tuesday, September 24, 2019

Online Infringement of IP - The Dark Side of the Digital Age

The Internet today has efficiently created a wide range of opportunities for business firms, companies, organizations, and individuals to communicate their brand messages and reach their target audience. However, keeping aside the Internet's openness, versatility, and global reach, its unregulated character has created a fertile ground for Trademark and Copyright Infringement too. In the broadest sense, online Intellectual Property (IP) infringement covers the sale of counterfeit products and services through the Internet and a variety of its activities, including cybersquatting, phishing, SEO, and unsolicited email marketing. These activities make up for what we may refer to as the dark side of the digital era.



According to various reports and surveys conducted, the fastest growing area of counterfeit trading and Intellectual Property Infringement is online. Companies can't nowadays depend on conventional legal remedies for dealing with trademark and copyright abuse on the Internet. Therefore, they must build a proactive and multi-faceted strategy for Copyright and Trademark Protection, which must offer effective methods of adapting to the challenges of the online environment. It should also help the companies in overcoming some of the limitations in the conventional legal approach. For instance, like other forms of Intellectual Property Law, the Trademark Law is also governed by the principles of territoriality. However, on the Internet, it is quite easy to maintain an anonymous identity with the help of offshore internet servers. Consequently, the infringers with this kind of virtual presence can generate huge profits. The difficulties associated with the conventional legal approach leading to successful online IP infringement further includes the aspect of lack of uniformity in the legal landscape. Varying IP laws and regulations in different jurisdictions make it arduous to navigate the legal landscape.

Nevertheless, all is not lost yet as a growing number of technologies and monitoring services are now available to reduce IP violation, support online brand protection, and safeguard brand equity. As a company's brand and IP assets account for an extreme percentage of its overall business value, a strategic protection program is indispensable for protecting this highly valuable asset base.

AUTOMATED TRADEMARK MONITORING SYSTEMS

For preventing the Trademark Registration of confusingly similar or identical marks by third parties, automated trademark monitoring systems and services can prove to be extremely beneficial. With surveillance mechanisms, these systems monitor trademark use by third parties across product development, point of sale, and distribution. They also efficiently track activities involved in digital marketing, advertising, and social media marketing - that may have a bearing on the brand value and its entity and integrity. Furthermore, they help in signaling to infringers and violators that a trademark is actively protected.

PRIORITIES AND OPTIONS

As the Internet has immensely transformed the business landscape, it has become imperative to keep IP protection strategies in place and outsmart IP infringers in the online marketplace.
Rapidly putting a stop to online infringing activities should be the topmost priority. It requires immediate action for ensuring that no incriminating content is accessible online. Web screening companies linking up with various E-commerce platforms and internet service providers can detect and disable infringing websites and portals.

Claiming monetary damages from infringers can be a tough task, especially, in the present borderless digital society, where tracing the identity of an infringer is another complicated process. The courts and other authorities can help in stopping the illegal use of brands online by initiating legal proceedings against unauthorized use.

As the IP infringers are nowadays all equipped with the latest smart technologies and tools, the in-house legal departments and providers or specialized services can tackle such issues and provide solutions in a professional, cost-efficient, and responsible manner.

Monday, July 22, 2019

Marvel Wins Copyright Lawsuit Over 'Iron Man 3' Poster



Marvel Entertainment has finally won a Copyright Infringement lawsuit after four years that alleged the company had copied the design of their movie poster for "Iron Man 3" from two comic book artists' work.

Horizon Comics Production, owned by comic book artists and brothers Ben and Ray Lai, had sued Marvel in 2016 by claiming that the official poster of Iron Man 3 was way too similar to the appearance of a character named Caliban from their comic book series called Radix. In their lawsuit, Horizon claimed that six employees of Marvel were well aware of Radix and the design of Caliban. Additionally, the Copyright Infringement Lawsuit read that two of those employees had even worked with the comic artists and influenced the creators of the Iron Man 3 poster.
However, J. Paul Oetken, a US District Judge in New York, in his ruling asserted that the poster was designed based on inspiration boards made by Marvel's creative team, images from the movies of Iron Man, and a photoshoot starring Robert Downey Jr. To this, Horizon argued by saying that the two works were strikingly identical, and even produced an expert report discussing the aspects of anatomical structures and camera views. But the judge sided with Marvel by pointing out the differences in the pose, placement of lights, and overall coloring.  At last, the judge stated that in contrast to Horizon's no virtual evidence of copying in the records, Marvel was successful in introducing a piece of unrebutted evidence, which showed its independent creation of the Iron Man 3 poster.


Wednesday, July 17, 2019

YouTube Now Requires Timestamps in Copyright Claims


On YouTube, Copyright Claims are a necessary evil. Undoubtedly, they play a significant role in helping the copyright owners claim their content if another person uses it without giving them the proper credits. However, the manual claiming tool had been creating a lot of problems for both the large and small creators alike. Therefore, YouTube has now announced a few necessary changes to the way copyright claims are handled for making things easier for both the parties.


The first and foremost change involves the fact that the manual copyright claims will now require a timestamp to specify where the copyrighted content is used in a video. The video-sharing the website also stated that it would officially cancel a user's access to such manual claims if they repeatedly fail in providing accurate timestamps. YouTube will scan the uploaded videos against a database of files through which their content ID technology will find all the visual and audio matches. Any possible instances of Copyright Infringement found during that process will lead to automated generation of content ID claims or manual claims where the copyright owners themselves report a violation of their Intellectual Property.

The recipient of the manual claim will be able to see the timestamp specified by the reporting party. It will make it much easier for the recipient to figure out the part of the video to edit. If they decide to alter the video rather than disputing the claim, they can use the video editing tools in YouTube's Creator Studio section to remove the content associated with such claims. Creators can also mute the sounds in the time-stamped section or switch the music with the free songs in the Auto Library. Moreover, they can also trim the entire segment, if required.

YouTube stated that it would continue to make its editing tools more effective by eventually giving the creators a way to trim the claimed segments with a single click. YouTube’s Product Manager, Julian Bill, wrote that their work would not stop here as they would find even better ways to improve the copyright experience of creators while balancing the Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) of the copyright owners.

Understanding the Concept of Destination Branding through Trademark Protection

 The hospitality industry of India has undoubtedly become an exceedingly crucial service provider across the nation. Due to the increase in ...